Court of Protection

"Members are highly sought after for their expertise in health and welfare matters. The team is able to draw on the set's wider knowledge & experience in public law matters when advising on complex and cross-disciplinary cases, and is regularly instructed in sensitive mental capacity and residence matters."

Chambers UK Bar Guide

"Members are regularly called upon to act for the Official Solicitor, local authorities and professional advocate litigation friends in cases involving deprivation of liberty, forced marriage and the safeguarding of vulnerable adults."

Chambers UK Bar Guide

"Garden Court Chambers houses significant expertise across a wide range of health and welfare matters, drawing on the set’s additional strengths in family, public and human rights law."

Chambers UK Bar Guide

"Additional areas of strength for the set's barristers include forced marriage and deprivation of liberty disputes, and members act on behalf of protected parties and their families, the Official Solicitor and public bodies."

Chambers UK Bar Guide

"The chambers staff and clerks are always welcoming." "It is a first-rate set with first-rate clerking." "The clerks are professional and efficient."

Chambers UK Bar Guide

To contact the Court of Protection Clerks, please email copclerks@gclaw.co.uk or phone

+44 (0)20 7993 7600

Our busy Court of Protection barristers act in the Court of Protection and in the inherent jurisdiction for family members, the Official Solicitor, Accredited Legal Representatives, professional Relevant Person's Representatives and other litigation friends, local authorities and healthcare bodies.

Our team won 'Court of Protection Set of the Year' at the Legal 500 Bar Awards 2024.

Our members are recognised experts in health and welfare matters, Mental Health law, serious medical treatment and property and financial affairs matters.

Our team regularly act in complex cases raising intersecting issues, including deprivation of liberty of children and forced marriage. They act in and advise on related claims for damages.

Our unique Court of Protection team also offers unrivalled multidisciplinary expertise in complementary areas including community care, housing, education, immigration and family law. We pride ourselves on our strength across these disciplines which enables a holistic approach to cases.   

We accept instructions in court cases and advisory work from clients in all parts of England and Wales. Our barristers are regularly instructed on an urgent basis.

Team members deliver regular events and bespoke training on Court of Protection issues. Please see further details below.

Our Court of Protection webinars are available to watch on our YouTube channel via the Garden Court Chambers Court of Protection playlist.

our expertise

We cover the full range of areas under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 as well as cases under the High Court’s jurisdiction in:

  • Serious medical treatment applications

  • Overlap between Mental Health Act and Mental Capacity Act

  • Variety of personal welfare applications, including section 16 and whether it is in the person’s best interests to live in a family home, residential care or other care setting, disputes over arrangements for contact with family members, decisions on complex/interventionist care packages involving deprivation or restriction of liberty

  • Section 21A applications challenging authorisations of deprivation of liberty in a care home or hospital under the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DOLS)

  • Emergency applications in a variety of situations, including the transfer of a person lacking capacity to a new care setting, requiring a transfer plan with potential deprivation of liberty, requiring advance authorisation by the court on particular forms of restrictions, etc.

  • Emergency applications in relation to property / finance management

  • Contested applications for the appointment of deputies (welfare/financial affairs) and other property and affairs applications, e.g. issues arising under Lasting Powers of Attorney, such as applications by the Office of the Public Guardian to revoke the power

  • Proceedings concerning 16- and 17-year-olds, and the overlapping jurisdictions of the Court of Protection and Children Act 1989

  • Disputed responsibilities of different local authorities, including in relation to safeguarding duties and community care

  • Property and affairs disputes including statutory wills

Notable Cases

Our sector leading work in mental capacity issues includes:

Gloucestershire City Council v AB & Anor [2022] EWCOP 42: Capacity to access internet and limits on internet use in the light of serious consequences.

Upadrasta v The Commissioner of the City of London Police [2023] EWHC 1853 (KB): False imprisonment claim based on misapplication of powers under s136 of Mental Capacity Act 2003 proceeds notwithstanding procedural defects.

MOC v Secretary of State for Work And Pensions [2022] EWCA Civ 1: Powers of deputies, benefits, discrimination.

T (A Child), Re [2021] UKSC 35: Use of inherent jurisdiction of the High Court to permit child placement in unregistered accommodation.

Re E (Vaccine) [2021] EWCOP 7: Assessment of best interests for the purposes of COVID-17 vaccination of an 80-year-old resident of a care home with dementia diagnosis where son objecting to vaccination.

AG v (1) AM (by his litigation friend, the Official Solicitor) (2) LBE (3) MH (4) ECCG [2020] EWCOP 59: Assessment of best interests of a brain-injured man to move from a nursing home to be cared for at home by extended family and CCG-funded carers.

Re D (A child) [2019] UKSC 42: The leading case concerning the deprivation of liberty of 16 and 17 year-olds.

ASK, R (On the Application Of) v The Secretary of State for the Home Department [2019] EWCA Civ 1239: Immigration detention and removal of persons lacking capacity.

VC, R (On the Application Of) v The Secretary of State for the Home Department (Rev 1) [2018] EWCA Civ 57: Immigration detention of persons with mental illness and/or lacking capacity.

AB v HT, LB Hammersmith & Fulham, M (by her litigation friend the Official Solicitor) and MS [2018] EWCOP 2: Presumption of capacity for marriage, principles on fact finding in the Court of Protection.

AM (Afghanistan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2017] EWCA Civ 1123: Jurisdiction for appointment of litigation friend in the Immigration and Asylum Chamber tribunals.

Health Service Executive of Ireland v PA and Others [2015] EWCOP 38; [2015] WLR (D) 243: Scope and interpretation of Schedule 3 of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (International Protection of Adults).

Re X and others (Deprivation of Liberty) [2014] EWCOP 25; and [2014] EWCOP 37: Procedure for court-authorized deprivation of liberty following the expansion of the concept by the Supreme Court ruling in Cheshire West.

Islington LBC v QR [2014] EWCOP 26: Guidance on capacity to make decisions to enter a supported living tenancy.

An NHS Trust v Mrs P and Ms P (by her litigation friend the Official Solicitor) COP11984767: Capacity to make decision as to continuation with pregnancy. Read more in the BBC report.

 

TRAINING AND PUBLICATIONS

We are pleased to offer training to legal practitioners and organisations.

We provide webinars which are advertised on Chambers’ website; these are open to all and address key developments in this area of law. Watch our recorded events at Garden Court Chambers Court of Protection playlist.

We also offer bespoke training tailored to the training needs of those working in the dynamic context of Court of Protection.

Please contact the clerks to discuss how we may be able to help with any training needs you may have.

We provide case summaries and notes about recent developments in Court of Protection and other areas of social welfare law on our Social Welfare Updates page. Three members of our team are editors of the Community Care Law Reports.

 

Recent notable cases and news

Garden Court Chambers wins awards in four categories at Legal 500 Bar Awards 2024

We are delighted to announce that Garden Court Chambers has won four awards at The Legal 500 Bar Awards, held on Wednesday 25 September 2024.

26 September 2024

Garden Court Chambers welcomes Eleanor Sibley as a new tenant

We are delighted to announce that Eleanor Sibley has joined Garden Court Chambers as a new tenant.

19 September 2024

Garden Court Chambers shortlisted for record-breaking fourteen awards at The Legal 500 Bar Awards

We are delighted to announce that Garden Court Chambers has been shortlisted in a record-breaking fourteen categories at The Legal 500 Bar Awards.

9 July 2024

Ollie Persey wins Legal Aid Newcomer of the Year Award at LALY Awards 2024

We are delighted to announce that Ollie Persey is the winner of Legal Aid Newcomer of the Year at the 2024 Legal Aid Lawyer of the Year Awards.

8 July 2024

Nick Bano, Ollie Persey and Mia Hakl-Law shortlisted for LALY Awards 2024

Our warmest congratulations to Nick, Ollie and Mia for this outstanding achievement.

20 May 2024

Garden Court counsel successfully oppose Hospital Trust claim that orders permitting compulsory treatment can be implemented and extended by remote examinations

Garden Court’s Stephen Simblet KC and Ollie Persey acted for PQR, instructed by Deborah Robinson through Cartwright King Solicitors, with Garden Court’s Roger Pezzani and Alex Schymyck instructed by Rheian Davies on behalf of Mind.

20 December 2023

Garden Court secures top tier rankings in the Legal 500 UK 2024

Garden Court Chambers is proud to be recognised as a Top Tier set again in the Legal 500 UK 2024 rankings.

4 October 2023

New edition of Halsbury's Laws on Judicial Review

Ollie Persey of the Garden Court Chambers Public Law Team is the Consultant Editor of the latest edition of the highly regarded public law practitioner text, Halsbury’s Laws on Judicial Review, published this month.

21 July 2023

Garden Court Chambers shortlisted for record-breaking TEN awards at The Legal 500 Bar Awards

We are delighted to announce that Garden Court Chambers has been shortlisted in a record-breaking ten categories at The Legal 500 Bar Awards.

12 July 2023

Grainne Mellon and David Neale shortlisted for LALY Awards 2022

19 May 2022

Helen Foot, Emma Fenn and Gráinne Mellon appointed as Recorders

We are delighted to announce that Helen Foot (Call: 2008), Emma Fenn (Call: 2010) and Gráinne Mellon (Call: 2010) of Garden Court Chambers have been newly appointed as Recorders by the Queen.

26 January 2022

Suspension of DLA after 28 days in hospital did not violate Article 14 ECHR, in case of an adult patient with severe learning disabilities

The Appellant was represented by Amanda Weston QC, Desmond Rutledge and Ollie Persey of Garden Court Chambers instructed by Merseyside Law Centre (Samantha Maher, Trainee Solicitor).

13 January 2022

Nicola Braganza, Mark Gatley and Liz Davies of Garden Court Chambers to be appointed Queen’s Counsel

Garden Court Chambers is delighted to announce that Nicola Braganza, Mark Gatley and Liz Davies of Garden Court Chambers will be formally appointed Queen’s Counsel in 2022.

22 December 2021

Gráinne Mellon highly commended at Bar Pro Bono Awards 2021 in the 'Junior Pro Bono Barrister of the Year' category

We are delighted to announce Gráinne Mellon of Garden Court Chambers was highly commended in the 'Junior Pro Bono Barrister of the Year' category at the Bar Pro Bono Awards 2021

3 November 2021

Gráinne Mellon shortlisted for International Bar Association's Pro Bono Award 2021

We are delighted to announce Gráinne Mellon of Garden Court Chambers has been shortlisted for the International Bar Association's Pro Bono Award 2021 for her incredible work helping vulnerable EU children and families apply to the EU Settlement Scheme.

28 October 2021

Garden Court secures number one rankings in Chambers UK Bar Guide 2022

21 October 2021

Gráinne Mellon acts in first Court of Protection case concerning Covid-19 Vaccination and the Mental Capacity Act

Gráinne Mellon of the Court of Protection Team was instructed on behalf of Mrs E, by her Accredited Legal Representative, Keith Clarke of Burke Niazi Solicitors.

28 January 2021

On International Day of Older Persons our Court of Protection barristers write about why human rights are needed now more than ever

Blog post by the Garden Court Chambers Court of Protection Team.

1 October 2020

Garden Court Chambers welcomes Abigail Holt as a new tenant

7 September 2020

Garden Court Chambers ranked in Band 1 in Chambers UK Bar Guide 2020

We are delighted to have once again been ranked in Band 1 by Chambers and Partners in the Chambers UK Bar Guide 2020.

17 October 2019

High Court’s inherent jurisdiction for the protection of vulnerable adults (Southend-on-Sea Borough Council v Meyers)

20 March 2019

Catrin Lewis appointed Fee Paid Judge in the Court of Protection

We are delighted to announce that Catrin Lewis has been appointed Fee Paid Judge in the Court of Protection.

30 January 2019

Garden Court Chambers ranked in Band 1 in Chambers UK Bar Guide 2019

We are delighted to have once again been ranked in Band 1 by Chambers and Partners in the Chambers UK Bar Guide 2019.

5 November 2018

Garden Court Chambers is delighted to welcome back Artis Kakonge from her sabbatical

Artis is returning to Chambers after spending the past few years working in local government.

5 February 2018

Upper Tribunal gives guidance on age assessments

Tessa Buchanan appeared for the applicant, AS. 

9 November 2017

Garden Court is delighted to announce that all four of the pupils who started in October 2016 have accepted offers of tenancy at the end of their pupillage

Stephen Clark, Tihomir Mak, Laura Profumo and Franck Magennis have joined Chambers as full members and have already started developing their practices.

1 November 2017

Bach Commission report calls for Rights to Justice Act and far wider eligibility for legal aid

Garden Court Chambers contributed evidence to the Bach Commission.

22 September 2017

Proof magazine #3: ‘Life in the Justice Gap: Why legal aid matters’ launch supported by Garden Court Chambers

Garden Court Chambers is proud to sponsor Proof magazine. The third issue of Proof was co-produced by the Justice Gap and the Justice Alliance.

20 July 2017

Garden Court Chambers extends condolences and solidarity to all those affected by Grenfell Tower tragedy

Garden Court Chambers is horrified by the fire at Grenfell Towers. We extend our condolences and our solidarity to all those bereaved, injured or rendered homeless.

16 June 2017

Leslie Thomas QC, Judy Khan QC and Marc Willers QC elected as Joint Heads of Chambers

Garden Court is delighted to announce that Leslie Thomas QC, Judy Khan QC and Marc Willers QC have been elected as Joint Heads of Chambers.

31 January 2017

Garden Court Chambers ranked in Band 1 in Chambers UK Bar Guide 2017

We are delighted to have once again been ranked in Band 1 by Chambers and Partners in the Chambers UK Bar Guide 2017.

2 November 2016

We are top ranked by independent legal directories and consistently win awards.

+ View more awards